Ducks Unlimited
On the $100 decision scale
- Cash you keep
- $75
- From your cash
- $5
- Donation support
- $5
- Total to organization
- $10
If selected: $7.50 cash to you. $0.50 from your cash + $0.50 support = $1 to Ducks Unlimited.
ECON 341 · Natural Resource Economics Instructor: Byeong-Hak Choe SUNY Geneseo · Fall 2026
Natural ResourceWhat our choices reveal about the value of giving
Byeong-Hak Choe
October 26, 2026
library(tidyverse)
forest_dir <- "../scripts/forest-choice"
source(file.path(forest_dir, "analysis.R"))
source(file.path(forest_dir, "model.R"))
source(file.path(forest_dir, "student-figures.R"))
source(file.path(forest_dir, "student-cards.R"))
activity <- forest_load_responses(
params$responses_csv, file.path(forest_dir, "choice-design.csv"), params$run_id
)
responses <- as_tibble(activity$data)
choices <- responses |> filter(selected == 1)
people <- n_distinct(choices$participant_id)
decisions <- nrow(choices)
percent <- function(x) scales::percent(x, accuracy = 0.1)
money <- function(x) sprintf("$%.2f", x)
donation_share <- mean(choices$recipient != "NONE")
is_synthetic <- str_starts(activity$run_id, "SYNTHETIC-")
fit_error <- NULL
fit <- tryCatch(forest_fit_choice_model(responses), error = function(error) {
fit_error <<- conditionMessage(error)
NULL
})
coefficients <- if (!is.null(fit)) as_tibble(fit$coefficients) else tibble()
mwtp <- if (!is.null(fit)) as_tibble(fit$marginal_wtp) else
tibble(estimate = NA_real_, conf_low = NA_real_, conf_high = NA_real_)
report_mwtp <- all(is.finite(c(mwtp$estimate, mwtp$conf_low, mwtp$conf_high)))
show_example <- report_mwtp && between(mwtp$estimate, 0, 1)
matched_choices <- choices |> filter(card_id %in% sprintf("C%02d", 1:4))How much of your own cash would you give up to send more money to nature? Each card offered two donations and the option to keep all your cash. Changing the offers let us examine three influences: your cost, the gift received, and the organization receiving it.
Under the payment rule, each selected person had $8 available to keep or contribute, plus the donation support attached to the chosen offer.
cat(sprintf('<div class="fc-results-stats" aria-label="Our class choices">
<div class="fc-results-stat"><strong>%s</strong><span>participants</span></div>
<div class="fc-results-stat"><strong>%s</strong><span>choices, twelve per person</span></div>
<div class="fc-results-stat"><strong>%s</strong><span>of choices selected a donation</span></div>
</div>', people, decisions, percent(donation_share)))These are our class’s recorded choices, summarized without individual response histories. The donation percentage describes choices, rather than the percentage of people who always donated. Keeping cash was a valid option throughout.
The choice comparisons below use the amounts displayed on the cards. The payment rule uses 10%: giving up $5 on a card costs $0.50 in cash. Keeping all $80 on the card meant keeping $8 actual cash.
The regression and money trade-off later on use actual dollars.
Everyone saw the same offers, with card order and left/right positions shuffled. The C01–C12 labels below identify the offers, rather than their screen order.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $7.50 cash to you. $0.50 from your cash + $0.50 support = $1 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $7.50 cash to you. $0.50 from your cash + $0.50 support = $1 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $6 cash to you. $2 from your cash + $2 support = $4 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $6 cash to you. $2 from your cash + $2 support = $4 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $5 cash to you. $3 from your cash + $1 support = $4 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $5 cash to you. $3 from your cash + $1 support = $4 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $0 cash to you. $8 from your cash + $2 support = $10 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $0 cash to you. $8 from your cash + $2 support = $10 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $7.50 cash to you. $0.50 from your cash + $0.50 support = $1 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $7 cash to you. $1 from your cash + $0 support = $1 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $7 cash to you. $1 from your cash + $0 support = $1 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $7.50 cash to you. $0.50 from your cash + $0.50 support = $1 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $6.50 cash to you. $1.50 from your cash + $0.50 support = $2 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $6.50 cash to you. $1.50 from your cash + $1.50 support = $3 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $6.50 cash to you. $1.50 from your cash + $1.50 support = $3 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $6.50 cash to you. $1.50 from your cash + $0.50 support = $2 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $5 cash to you. $3 from your cash + $2 support = $5 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $3 cash to you. $5 from your cash + $0 support = $5 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $3 cash to you. $5 from your cash + $0 support = $5 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $5 cash to you. $3 from your cash + $2 support = $5 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $4 cash to you. $4 from your cash + $0 support = $4 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $4 cash to you. $4 from your cash + $2 support = $6 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Original offers · display amounts are paid at 10%
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $4 cash to you. $4 from your cash + $2 support = $6 to Ducks Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $4 cash to you. $4 from your cash + $0 support = $4 to Trout Unlimited.
On the $100 decision scale
If selected: $8 cash to you; no donation. The $2 support is unused.
Only one saved card for each of two selected people is implemented under the announced rule. The choices below do not verify which payments were made.
First, hold the gift fixed. On C05 and C06, either organization would receive $10 on the card. One offer cost you $5, while the other cost $10. The cheaper offer received more instructor support.
Next, hold your cost fixed. On C07 and C08, either donation cost you $15 on the card. One delivered $20, while the other delivered $30. Support made up the difference.
Enlarge the choice comparisons
Same gift, different cost: 68.2% of decisions selected the $5 contribution, compared with 9.1% for the $10 contribution.
Same cost, different gift: 65.9% selected the $30 gift, compared with 9.1% for the $20 gift.
Each comparison combines two decisions per participant. The organizations switched financial offers between the two cards. This helps us look beyond a preference for one recipient. The bars summarize what this class chose; they do not prove that cost or support alone caused every difference.
The economic idea: people can care about both what they give up and what conservation receives. A donation is not simply a yes-or-no attitude toward nature; its financial terms matter.
On C01–C04, the two organizations had identical financial terms within each card. Across those 88 choices, 23.9% selected Ducks Unlimited, 34.1% selected Trout Unlimited, and 42.0% kept cash.
Recipients can matter because people care about different habitats or trust organizations differently. These class shares alone do not establish a precise preference for the wider public.
The bars compare particular offers. The regression uses all twelve cards to examine personal cost and total gift while accounting for the recipient and the competing offer. It also accounts for each participant making repeated decisions when calculating uncertainty.
For either donation option, we estimate:
\begin{aligned} &\log\left(\frac{p_{itj}}{p_{it0}}\right)\\ &\quad=\alpha_{DU}\,DU_{itj}+\alpha_{TU}\,TU_{itj}\\ &\qquad+\beta_g\,\text{Gift}_{itj}+\beta_c\,\text{Cost}_{itj}. \end{aligned}
Read the left side as “this donation offer compared with keeping cash.” p_{itj} is the predicted chance that participant i chooses option j on card t; p_{it0} is the chance of keeping all $8. The ratio compares those two chances. Its natural logarithm puts the comparison on the regression’s scale: zero means equally likely, a positive value means the donation is more likely, and a negative value means keeping cash is more likely.
On the right, Gift is the total actual dollars reaching the organization, including support, and Cost is the actual cash the participant gives up. DU and TU are indicators—1 for that organization and 0 otherwise—so the regression can account for a preference for one recipient. The coefficients are shared across the class; the figure below focuses on the two money coefficients, \beta_g and \beta_c.
i = participant, t = card, and j = option. These correspond to participant_id, card_id (such as C07), and recipient in the prepared data frame. Option 0 means keeping cash (NONE); the other options are DU and TU. The card ID identifies the menu, rather than its screen order.
One row describes one available option (i,t,j). Three rows describe one decision (i,t), because each card offered three options. Only the chosen row has selected = 1. That observed choice differs from p_{itj}, the probability predicted by the regression.
if (!is.null(fit)) {
cat(paste0(
'- **Personal cost:** the negative estimate means that giving up more cash ',
'made a donation less attractive relative to keeping cash, with the gift ',
'and recipient held fixed.\n\n',
'- **Total gift:** the positive estimate means that sending more to ',
'the organization made a donation more attractive, with personal cost ',
'and recipient held fixed.\n\n'))
} else {
cat('Without a reliable fit, we cannot report an estimated direction for ',
'cost or gift. The choice comparisons above still describe the recorded decisions.\n\n')
}Personal cost: the negative estimate means that giving up more cash made a donation less attractive relative to keeping cash, with the gift and recipient held fixed.
Total gift: the positive estimate means that sending more to the organization made a donation more attractive, with personal cost and recipient held fixed.
The lines show uncertainty. When shown, they are approximate confidence intervals for the estimates, rather than a range containing 95% of students’ preferences.
A coefficient is not a percentage-point change in choice probability. For this page, focus on the direction and uncertainty. The extended explanation works through the probability ratios and log relative odds with numerical examples.
Suppose an offer sends one extra dollar to the same organization. How much more cash would you give up to make that happen?
Think of two opposing effects: a larger gift can make the offer more attractive, while giving up more of your own cash can make it less attractive. The regression lets us estimate the extra personal cost at which these two changes balance. All amounts in this section are actual dollars, after applying the card’s 10% payment rule.
if (report_mwtp) {
gift_slope <- coefficients$estimate[coefficients$term == "donation_dollars"]
cost_slope <- coefficients$estimate[coefficients$term == "cost_dollars"]
slope_number <- function(x) sprintf("%.3f", x)
gift_direction <- if (gift_slope >= 0) "raises" else "lowers"
cat(paste0(
'**How do we calculate the dollar trade-off?** An extra $1 delivered ',
gift_direction, ' the offer’s appeal by **', slope_number(abs(gift_slope)),
'** on the regression’s scale. Each extra actual $1 given up lowers it by **',
slope_number(-cost_slope), '**. If $x$ is the extra personal cash cost, ',
'the two changes balance when $', slope_number(gift_slope),
' - ', slope_number(-cost_slope), 'x = 0$:\n\n',
'$$\n',
'\\begin{aligned}\n',
'\\widehat{\\text{MWTP}}&=-\\frac{\\hat\\beta_g}{\\hat\\beta_c}\\\\\n',
'&=\\frac{', slope_number(gift_slope), '}{', slope_number(-cost_slope),
'}\\approx ', sprintf("%.2f", mwtp$estimate), '.\n',
'\\end{aligned}\n$$\n\n',
'Both coefficients use the **same regression scale**. Dividing cancels ',
'that scale, leaving **actual dollars of personal cash given up per extra ',
'actual dollar delivered**.\n\n'
))
} else {
cat('The dollar trade-off is the gift coefficient divided by the size of ',
'the negative personal-cost coefficient. We do not show a numerical ',
'ratio because this run does not support a reliable MWTP estimate.\n\n')
}How do we calculate the dollar trade-off? An extra $1 delivered raises the offer’s appeal by 1.028 on the regression’s scale. Each extra actual $1 given up lowers it by 1.507. If x is the extra personal cash cost, the two changes balance when 1.028 - 1.507x = 0:
\begin{aligned} \widehat{\text{MWTP}}&=-\frac{\hat\beta_g}{\hat\beta_c}\\ &=\frac{1.028}{1.507}\approx 0.68. \end{aligned}
Both coefficients use the same regression scale. Dividing cancels that scale, leaving actual dollars of personal cash given up per extra actual dollar delivered.
About $0.68 more cash given up for an extra $1 reaching the same organization. That is money the selected person could otherwise keep.
Marginal means “for one more unit.” Here, that unit is one additional dollar delivered, starting from an existing donation offer. The estimate summarizes the trade-off in our class’s choices.
Start with an offer in which you contribute $4 of your $8, keep $4, and the organization receives $4. Now consider a revised offer that sends $5 to the same organization:
if (show_example) {
tibble(
`Where money goes` = c("From your cash", "Cash you keep",
"Donation support", "Organization receives"),
`Starting offer` = c(4, 4, 0, 4),
`Illustrative revised offer` = c(4 + mwtp$estimate, 4 - mwtp$estimate,
1 - mwtp$estimate, 5)
) |>
mutate(across(where(is.numeric), money)) |>
knitr::kable()
} else {
knitr::asis_output("A numerical offsetting offer is not shown because the estimated trade-off is unavailable or outside this feasible comparison.")
}| Where money goes | Starting offer | Illustrative revised offer |
|---|---|---|
| From your cash | $4.00 | $4.68 |
| Cash you keep | $4.00 | $3.32 |
| Donation support | $0.00 | $0.32 |
| Organization receives | $4.00 | $5.00 |
You keep $0.68 less; conservation receives $1 more. Your additional $0.68 and an additional $0.32 of donation support together fund that extra dollar. The support is paid to the organization.
if (show_example) {
personal_cents <- as.integer(round(100 * mwtp$estimate))
support_cents <- 100L - personal_cents
flow_colours <- .forest_student_visuals$nre_colour(c(
"cost_dark", "policy", "benefit_dark", "canvas", "ink", "grid_major"
))
cat(sprintf('```{=html}
<figure id="extra-dollar-visual" class="fc-money-flow"
aria-labelledby="extra-dollar-title" aria-describedby="extra-dollar-note"
style="--fc-flow-cost:%s; --fc-flow-support:%s; --fc-flow-gift:%s; --fc-flow-paper:%s; --fc-flow-ink:%s; --fc-flow-line:%s;">
<figcaption id="extra-dollar-title">Where the extra $1 comes from</figcaption>
<div class="fc-money-equation">
<div class="fc-money-part fc-money-personal">
<strong>%d¢</strong><span>More from your cash</span>
<small>You keep %d¢ less</small>
</div>
<span class="fc-money-operator" role="img" aria-label="plus">+</span>
<div class="fc-money-part fc-money-support">
<strong>%d¢</strong><span>Extra donation support</span>
<small>Added by the instructor</small>
</div>
<span class="fc-money-operator" role="img" aria-label="equals">=</span>
<div class="fc-money-part fc-money-total">
<strong>$1</strong><span>Extra to conservation</span>
<small>To the same organization</small>
</div>
</div>
<p id="extra-dollar-note" class="fc-money-note">Actual dollars · Rounded model example · All three amounts show the change from the starting offer.</p>
</figure>\n```\n',
flow_colours[1], flow_colours[2], flow_colours[3], flow_colours[4],
flow_colours[5], flow_colours[6], personal_cents, personal_cents,
support_cents))
}Actual dollars · Rounded model example · All three amounts show the change from the starting offer.
What does “balance” mean?
Under the fitted model, the larger gift is just attractive enough to compensate for the extra cash given up. The model predicts the same chance of choosing this offer as before, when the other options remain unchanged. Individual students can still prefer different offers.
if (show_example) {
cat(paste0(
'For the **same extra $1 delivered**, the model predicts:\n\n',
'- **Less than ', money(mwtp$estimate), ' extra from your cash:** ',
'the revised offer becomes more attractive and more likely to be chosen.\n',
'- **About ', money(mwtp$estimate), ' extra:** the two changes balance.\n',
'- **More than ', money(mwtp$estimate), ' extra:** the additional cash ',
'cost outweighs the larger gift, making the offer less likely to be chosen.\n\n'
))
}For the same extra $1 delivered, the model predicts:
The revised offer illustrates a model prediction; it was not an additional card or an actual payment.
The approximate 95% confidence interval is $0.60–$0.76 per extra $1 delivered. We estimated the trade-off from a small set of class choices, so $0.68 is not an exact, known amount. The interval summarizes uncertainty about the model’s estimated trade-off; it is not a range containing 95% of students’ individual willingness to pay.
Willingness to pay (WTP) concerns how much someone would give up for a specified outcome. Marginal WTP concerns an additional improvement from a starting point. Here, we ask about one more dollar reaching the organization, rather than the largest total donation someone would make.
The $0.68 estimate does not mean that everyone would donate that amount or that it is anyone’s maximum donation. It is a dollar trade-off, rather than a probability of donating.
We estimated a cash-for-donation trade-off under this activity’s payment rules. We did not find each person’s maximum donation or the total value of nature. Donations can reflect concern for conservation, trust in an organization, and satisfaction from giving. A defined park improvement would be a different object of choice.
1. Why might a larger gift be more attractive when your personal cost is unchanged?
You keep the same cash, while conservation receives more. Additional support makes that possible. Someone who values the organization’s work may prefer the larger gift, although the other organization and keeping cash remain available.
2. Could someone value nature even if they never visit the places receiving support?
Yes. Someone may value knowing that habitat or wildlife continues to exist, or preserving it for future generations. These are existence and bequest values. Visits are one source of value, but they are not the only one.
3. Why should we avoid calling the MWTP estimate “the value of nature”?
It concerns an extra dollar sent to a particular organization under specific cash and support rules. It does not specify a guaranteed ecological outcome, recover each person’s exact maximum payment, or measure every benefit of nature. This class is also a small, nonrepresentative sample.
Explore the full results and methods for all twelve card shares, data preparation, the regression equation, coefficient interpretation, and the MWTP calculation.
---
title: "Classwork 6: Cash or Conservation?"
subtitle: "What our choices reveal about the value of giving"
date: 2026-10-26
css:
- ../assets/css/econ-341-forest-choice.css
- ../assets/css/econ-341-forest-choice-results.css
format:
html:
code-fold: true
code-summary: "Show R code"
code-tools: true
html-math-method: katex
link-external-newwindow: true
execute:
eval: true
echo: true
warning: false
message: false
params:
responses_csv: "../scripts/forest-choice/data/2026-10-26/Responses-class-clean.csv"
run_id: "CONSERVATION-CLASS-01"
---
```{r}
#| label: prepare-student-results
library(tidyverse)
forest_dir <- "../scripts/forest-choice"
source(file.path(forest_dir, "analysis.R"))
source(file.path(forest_dir, "model.R"))
source(file.path(forest_dir, "student-figures.R"))
source(file.path(forest_dir, "student-cards.R"))
activity <- forest_load_responses(
params$responses_csv, file.path(forest_dir, "choice-design.csv"), params$run_id
)
responses <- as_tibble(activity$data)
choices <- responses |> filter(selected == 1)
people <- n_distinct(choices$participant_id)
decisions <- nrow(choices)
percent <- function(x) scales::percent(x, accuracy = 0.1)
money <- function(x) sprintf("$%.2f", x)
donation_share <- mean(choices$recipient != "NONE")
is_synthetic <- str_starts(activity$run_id, "SYNTHETIC-")
fit_error <- NULL
fit <- tryCatch(forest_fit_choice_model(responses), error = function(error) {
fit_error <<- conditionMessage(error)
NULL
})
coefficients <- if (!is.null(fit)) as_tibble(fit$coefficients) else tibble()
mwtp <- if (!is.null(fit)) as_tibble(fit$marginal_wtp) else
tibble(estimate = NA_real_, conf_low = NA_real_, conf_high = NA_real_)
report_mwtp <- all(is.finite(c(mwtp$estimate, mwtp$conf_low, mwtp$conf_high)))
show_example <- report_mwtp && between(mwtp$estimate, 0, 1)
matched_choices <- choices |> filter(card_id %in% sprintf("C%02d", 1:4))
```
## 1. What were we trying to learn?
**How much of your own cash would you give up to send more money to nature?**
Each card offered two donations and the option to keep all your cash. Changing
the offers let us examine three influences: **your cost, the gift received,
and the organization receiving it**.
Under the payment rule, each selected person had **$8 available to keep or
contribute**, plus the donation support attached to the chosen offer.
```{r}
#| label: class-choice-overview
#| results: asis
cat(sprintf('<div class="fc-results-stats" aria-label="Our class choices">
<div class="fc-results-stat"><strong>%s</strong><span>participants</span></div>
<div class="fc-results-stat"><strong>%s</strong><span>choices, twelve per person</span></div>
<div class="fc-results-stat"><strong>%s</strong><span>of choices selected a donation</span></div>
</div>', people, decisions, percent(donation_share)))
```
`r if (is_synthetic) "**Practice data:** these choices were simulated." else "These are our class’s recorded choices, summarized without individual response histories."`
The donation percentage describes **choices**, rather than the percentage of
people who always donated. Keeping cash was a valid option throughout.
::: {.callout-note title="Recognize the card amounts"}
The choice comparisons below use the **amounts displayed on the cards**.
The payment rule uses **10%**: giving up **$5 on a card costs $0.50 in cash**.
Keeping all **$80 on the card** meant keeping **$8 actual cash**.
The regression and money trade-off later on use **actual dollars**.
:::
::: {.callout-note title="Revisit the twelve original cards" collapse="true"}
Everyone saw the same offers, with card order and left/right positions shuffled.
The C01–C12 labels below identify the offers, rather than their screen order.
```{r}
#| label: revisit-original-cards
forest_student_card_gallery(activity$design)
```
Only one saved card for each of two selected people is implemented under the
announced rule. The choices below do not verify which payments were made.
:::
## 2. Two comparisons make the trade-offs visible
**First, hold the gift fixed.** On C05 and C06, either organization would
receive **$10 on the card**. One offer cost you **$5**, while the other cost
**$10**. The cheaper offer received more instructor support.
**Next, hold your cost fixed.** On C07 and C08, either donation cost you
**$15 on the card**. One delivered **$20**, while the other delivered **$30**.
Support made up the difference.
```{r}
#| label: fig-student-choice-comparisons
#| fig-width: 8
#| fig-height: 6
#| fig-cap: "Two pairs of cards reveal different trade-offs. Each comparison includes both donation options and keeping all cash. Amounts use the original card scale; actual payments are 10%."
#| fig-alt: "Choice shares for two comparisons: a fixed gift with different personal costs, and a fixed personal cost with different gifts. Both include keeping all cash."
comparison_shares <- forest_student_comparison_counts(responses)
forest_student_tradeoff_plot(comparison_shares)
```
[Enlarge the choice comparisons](econ-341-cw-06_files/figure-html/fig-student-choice-comparisons-1.png){target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"}
**Same gift, different cost:** `r percent(comparison_shares$share[comparison_shares$option == "low_cost"])`
of decisions selected the $5 contribution, compared with
`r percent(comparison_shares$share[comparison_shares$option == "high_cost"])` for the $10 contribution.
**Same cost, different gift:** `r percent(comparison_shares$share[comparison_shares$option == "large_gift"])`
selected the $30 gift, compared with
`r percent(comparison_shares$share[comparison_shares$option == "small_gift"])` for the $20 gift.
Each comparison combines **two decisions per participant**. The organizations
switched financial offers between the two cards. This helps us look beyond
a preference for one recipient. The bars summarize what this class chose;
they do not prove that cost or support alone caused every difference.
**The economic idea:** people can care about both **what they give up** and
**what conservation receives**. A donation is not simply a yes-or-no attitude
toward nature; its financial terms matter.
### Did the organization matter?
On C01–C04, the two organizations had identical financial terms within each
card. Across those `r nrow(matched_choices)` choices, **`r percent(mean(matched_choices$recipient == "DU"))`
selected Ducks Unlimited**, **`r percent(mean(matched_choices$recipient == "TU"))`
selected Trout Unlimited**, and **`r percent(mean(matched_choices$recipient == "NONE"))`
kept cash**.
Recipients can matter because people care about different habitats or trust
organizations differently. These class shares alone do not establish a
precise preference for the wider public.
## 3. What does the regression add?
The bars compare particular offers. The regression uses **all twelve cards**
to examine personal cost and total gift while accounting for the recipient
and the competing offer. It also accounts for each participant making
repeated decisions when calculating uncertainty.
### The regression equation, in words and symbols
For either donation option, we estimate:
$$
\begin{aligned}
&\log\left(\frac{p_{itj}}{p_{it0}}\right)\\
&\quad=\alpha_{DU}\,DU_{itj}+\alpha_{TU}\,TU_{itj}\\
&\qquad+\beta_g\,\text{Gift}_{itj}+\beta_c\,\text{Cost}_{itj}.
\end{aligned}
$$
**Read the left side as “this donation offer compared with keeping cash.”**
$p_{itj}$ is the predicted chance that participant $i$ chooses option $j$
on card $t$; $p_{it0}$ is the chance of keeping all $8. The ratio compares
those two chances. Its natural logarithm puts the comparison on the
regression’s scale: **zero means equally likely**, a positive value means
the donation is more likely, and a negative value means keeping cash is
more likely.
On the right, **Gift** is the total actual dollars reaching the organization,
including support, and **Cost** is the actual cash the participant gives up.
$DU$ and $TU$ are indicators—1 for that organization and 0 otherwise—so the
regression can account for a preference for one recipient. The coefficients
are shared across the class; the figure below focuses on the two money
coefficients, $\beta_g$ and $\beta_c$.
::: {.callout-note title="How the subscripts match the response data"}
**$i$ = participant, $t$ = card, and $j$ = option.** These correspond to
`participant_id`, `card_id` (such as C07), and `recipient` in the prepared
data frame. Option $0$ means keeping cash (`NONE`); the other options are
`DU` and `TU`. The card ID identifies the menu, rather than its screen order.
**One row describes one available option $(i,t,j)$.** Three rows describe
one decision $(i,t)$, because each card offered three options. Only the
chosen row has `selected = 1`. That observed choice differs from $p_{itj}$,
the probability predicted by the regression.
:::
```{r}
#| label: fig-student-financial-results
#| fig-width: 8
#| fig-height: 4
#| fig-cap: "Regression estimates with approximate 95% confidence intervals. Monetary changes are one actual dollar. A negative coefficient lowers an offer’s appeal relative to keeping cash; a positive coefficient raises it, holding the other included attributes fixed."
#| fig-alt: "Two regression coefficient estimates with 95 percent confidence intervals: personal cost is negative and total gift is positive."
if (!is.null(fit)) {
forest_student_financial_plot(coefficients)
} else {
knitr::asis_output(paste("A reliable regression could not be estimated:",
fit_error, "The descriptive choices above are still valid."))
}
```
```{r}
#| label: read-student-regression
#| results: asis
if (!is.null(fit)) {
cat(paste0(
'- **Personal cost:** the negative estimate means that giving up more cash ',
'made a donation less attractive relative to keeping cash, with the gift ',
'and recipient held fixed.\n\n',
'- **Total gift:** the positive estimate means that sending more to ',
'the organization made a donation more attractive, with personal cost ',
'and recipient held fixed.\n\n'))
} else {
cat('Without a reliable fit, we cannot report an estimated direction for ',
'cost or gift. The choice comparisons above still describe the recorded decisions.\n\n')
}
```
**The lines show uncertainty.** When shown, they are approximate confidence
intervals for the estimates, rather than a range containing 95% of students’ preferences.
A coefficient is **not a percentage-point change in choice probability**.
For this page, focus on the direction and uncertainty. The
[extended explanation](../econ-cw-q/econ-341-cw-06-extended.html)
works through the probability ratios and log relative odds with numerical
examples.
## 4. Turn the trade-off into dollars
**Suppose an offer sends one extra dollar to the same organization. How
much more cash would you give up to make that happen?**
Think of two opposing effects: **a larger gift can make the offer more
attractive**, while **giving up more of your own cash can make it less
attractive**. The regression lets us estimate the extra personal cost at
which these two changes balance. All amounts in this section are **actual
dollars**, after applying the card’s 10% payment rule.
```{r}
#| label: calculate-student-mwtp
#| results: asis
if (report_mwtp) {
gift_slope <- coefficients$estimate[coefficients$term == "donation_dollars"]
cost_slope <- coefficients$estimate[coefficients$term == "cost_dollars"]
slope_number <- function(x) sprintf("%.3f", x)
gift_direction <- if (gift_slope >= 0) "raises" else "lowers"
cat(paste0(
'**How do we calculate the dollar trade-off?** An extra $1 delivered ',
gift_direction, ' the offer’s appeal by **', slope_number(abs(gift_slope)),
'** on the regression’s scale. Each extra actual $1 given up lowers it by **',
slope_number(-cost_slope), '**. If $x$ is the extra personal cash cost, ',
'the two changes balance when $', slope_number(gift_slope),
' - ', slope_number(-cost_slope), 'x = 0$:\n\n',
'$$\n',
'\\begin{aligned}\n',
'\\widehat{\\text{MWTP}}&=-\\frac{\\hat\\beta_g}{\\hat\\beta_c}\\\\\n',
'&=\\frac{', slope_number(gift_slope), '}{', slope_number(-cost_slope),
'}\\approx ', sprintf("%.2f", mwtp$estimate), '.\n',
'\\end{aligned}\n$$\n\n',
'Both coefficients use the **same regression scale**. Dividing cancels ',
'that scale, leaving **actual dollars of personal cash given up per extra ',
'actual dollar delivered**.\n\n'
))
} else {
cat('The dollar trade-off is the gift coefficient divided by the size of ',
'the negative personal-cost coefficient. We do not show a numerical ',
'ratio because this run does not support a reliable MWTP estimate.\n\n')
}
```
::: {.callout-important title="Our estimated marginal willingness to pay"}
`r if (report_mwtp) paste0("About **", money(mwtp$estimate), " more cash given up for an extra $1 reaching the same organization**. That is money the selected person could otherwise keep.") else "This run does not support a reliable numerical marginal willingness-to-pay estimate. The concept still describes the extra cash someone would give up for an extra dollar reaching the same organization."`
**Marginal** means “for one more unit.” Here, that unit is **one additional
dollar delivered**, starting from an existing donation offer. The estimate
summarizes the trade-off in our class’s choices.
:::
### Follow the money: what would change in an offer?
Start with an offer in which you contribute **$4 of your $8**, keep **$4**,
and the organization receives **$4**. Now consider a revised offer that
sends **$5 to the same organization**:
```{r}
#| label: student-money-tradeoff
if (show_example) {
tibble(
`Where money goes` = c("From your cash", "Cash you keep",
"Donation support", "Organization receives"),
`Starting offer` = c(4, 4, 0, 4),
`Illustrative revised offer` = c(4 + mwtp$estimate, 4 - mwtp$estimate,
1 - mwtp$estimate, 5)
) |>
mutate(across(where(is.numeric), money)) |>
knitr::kable()
} else {
knitr::asis_output("A numerical offsetting offer is not shown because the estimated trade-off is unavailable or outside this feasible comparison.")
}
```
`r if (show_example) paste0("**You keep ", money(mwtp$estimate), " less; conservation receives $1 more.** Your additional ", money(mwtp$estimate), " and an additional ", money(1 - mwtp$estimate), " of donation support together fund that extra dollar. The support is paid to the organization.") else "When a feasible estimate is available, the extra gift is funded by an additional personal contribution plus support."`
```{r}
#| label: student-extra-dollar-visual
#| results: asis
if (show_example) {
personal_cents <- as.integer(round(100 * mwtp$estimate))
support_cents <- 100L - personal_cents
flow_colours <- .forest_student_visuals$nre_colour(c(
"cost_dark", "policy", "benefit_dark", "canvas", "ink", "grid_major"
))
cat(sprintf('```{=html}
<figure id="extra-dollar-visual" class="fc-money-flow"
aria-labelledby="extra-dollar-title" aria-describedby="extra-dollar-note"
style="--fc-flow-cost:%s; --fc-flow-support:%s; --fc-flow-gift:%s; --fc-flow-paper:%s; --fc-flow-ink:%s; --fc-flow-line:%s;">
<figcaption id="extra-dollar-title">Where the extra $1 comes from</figcaption>
<div class="fc-money-equation">
<div class="fc-money-part fc-money-personal">
<strong>%d¢</strong><span>More from your cash</span>
<small>You keep %d¢ less</small>
</div>
<span class="fc-money-operator" role="img" aria-label="plus">+</span>
<div class="fc-money-part fc-money-support">
<strong>%d¢</strong><span>Extra donation support</span>
<small>Added by the instructor</small>
</div>
<span class="fc-money-operator" role="img" aria-label="equals">=</span>
<div class="fc-money-part fc-money-total">
<strong>$1</strong><span>Extra to conservation</span>
<small>To the same organization</small>
</div>
</div>
<p id="extra-dollar-note" class="fc-money-note">Actual dollars · Rounded model example · All three amounts show the change from the starting offer.</p>
</figure>\n```\n',
flow_colours[1], flow_colours[2], flow_colours[3], flow_colours[4],
flow_colours[5], flow_colours[6], personal_cents, personal_cents,
support_cents))
}
```
**What does “balance” mean?**
`r if (show_example) "Under the fitted model, the larger gift is just attractive enough to compensate for the extra cash given up. The model predicts **the same chance of choosing this offer** as before, when the other options remain unchanged. Individual students can still prefer different offers." else "A balancing trade-off would leave the offer’s predicted chance of being chosen unchanged: the extra gift would compensate for the extra personal cost, with the other options fixed. We do not show a numerical balancing offer for this run."`
```{r}
#| label: explain-student-marginal-tradeoff
#| results: asis
if (show_example) {
cat(paste0(
'For the **same extra $1 delivered**, the model predicts:\n\n',
'- **Less than ', money(mwtp$estimate), ' extra from your cash:** ',
'the revised offer becomes more attractive and more likely to be chosen.\n',
'- **About ', money(mwtp$estimate), ' extra:** the two changes balance.\n',
'- **More than ', money(mwtp$estimate), ' extra:** the additional cash ',
'cost outweighs the larger gift, making the offer less likely to be chosen.\n\n'
))
}
```
The revised offer illustrates a **model prediction**; it was not an
additional card or an actual payment.
### How certain is this trade-off?
`r if (report_mwtp) paste0("The approximate **95% confidence interval is ", money(mwtp$conf_low), "–", money(mwtp$conf_high), " per extra $1 delivered**. We estimated the trade-off from a small set of class choices, so ", money(mwtp$estimate), " is not an exact, known amount. The interval summarizes uncertainty about the model’s estimated trade-off; it is **not** a range containing 95% of students’ individual willingness to pay.") else "A reliable confidence interval is unavailable for this run. We should not attach a precise number to the trade-off."`
::: {.callout-note title="MWTP is different from a maximum donation"}
**Willingness to pay (WTP)** concerns how much someone would give up for a
specified outcome. **Marginal WTP** concerns an **additional improvement**
from a starting point. Here, we ask about one more dollar reaching the
organization, rather than the largest total donation someone would make.
`r if (report_mwtp) paste0("The ", money(mwtp$estimate), " estimate does not mean that everyone would donate that amount or that it is anyone’s maximum donation. It is a dollar trade-off, rather than a probability of donating.") else "A marginal trade-off does not reveal each person’s maximum total donation or their probability of donating."`
:::
::: {.callout-tip title="What can we say about the value of nature?"}
We estimated a cash-for-donation trade-off under this activity’s payment
rules. We did **not** find each person’s maximum donation or the total value
of nature. Donations can reflect concern for conservation, trust in an
organization, and satisfaction from giving. A defined park improvement
would be a different object of choice.
:::
## 5. Discuss
**1. Why might a larger gift be more attractive when your personal cost is unchanged?**
::: {.callout-tip title="Answer" collapse="true"}
You keep the same cash, while conservation receives more. Additional support
makes that possible. Someone who values the organization’s work may prefer
the larger gift, although the other organization and keeping cash remain
available.
:::
**2. Could someone value nature even if they never visit the places receiving support?**
::: {.callout-tip title="Answer" collapse="true"}
Yes. Someone may value knowing that habitat or wildlife continues to exist,
or preserving it for future generations. These are existence and bequest
values. Visits are one source of value, but they are not the only one.
:::
**3. Why should we avoid calling the MWTP estimate “the value of nature”?**
::: {.callout-tip title="Answer" collapse="true"}
It concerns an extra dollar sent to a particular organization under specific
cash and support rules. It does not specify a guaranteed ecological outcome,
recover each person’s exact maximum payment, or measure every benefit of
nature. This class is also a small, nonrepresentative sample.
:::
[Explore the full results and methods](../econ-cw-q/econ-341-cw-06-extended.html)
for all twelve card shares, data preparation, the regression equation,
coefficient interpretation, and the MWTP calculation.